Hi Brandon,
We have investigated the matter more thoroughly and have reinstated your accounts. I sincerely apologize for our error and the inconvenience you and your wife have gone through. I hope this will not deter you from fully enjoying the site in the future, and please do not hesitate to contact me if you experience any further problems.
Thank you,
Anjali
User Operations
Much thanks to the Metafilter posse for their help, both in public and behind the scenes for getting this correction made. It's great community of people.
and no, I doubt I'll be spending much time on Facebook.
Yes you will spend time there because that is where I stalk you the best.